October 12, 2005
Trivializing ideas to "one day ideas"
FYI: I am posting this email to check our thinking and so that our "one day ideas" don't become too complex.
From my email to Mike:
Thoughts on Overall concept:
I'm a bit concerned that we are trivializing ideas by calling them "one day ideas". I would highly doubt that any of the ideas we discuss, were executed in one single day. For example, savetoby.com probably got put together in a day... but the concept and business was woven over many months OR perhaps even years. There is a tendency to call things "one day ideas" because most of them depend on the web, and websites are simple to build.
Mike, you hit on the core of this thing when he was talking about inspiration versus perspiration. Perspiration is associated with money, time, and hard work. Inspiration is association with revelation, instant gratification, and no investment. This "onedayidea" concept stems from the fact that the internet enables inspiration; a single viral idea or story can generate physical and emotional capital, mobilize people, and instantaneously become the center of a national debate.
I don't mind calling it "onedayideas.com" , but perhaps we can keep ourselves productive by checking ideas against broad metrics like:
1) inspiration-ability of the concept:
2) controversy-driven; it's buzzworthiness
3) the sheer lack of effort and investment it takes to implement and manage after implementation
4) authenticity of story: sincerity and honesty seem to drive the successful ideas
5) measurable results (ie money, press/publicity, clicks, qualitative reponses)
This also raises the question: Should we consider onedayideas that are heavily, financially backed.
Posted at October 12, 2005 03:42 PM
| TrackBack
Richard,
You bring up some good points. As you can probably tell from my appropriation of your terms in later posts, I like how you define the split between inspiration and perspiration. I think most of us agree that inspiration is the fun part. Especially when it occur in a dynamic, collaborative forum such as this blog; which allows discussions without requiring advanced planning .
I would go even farther, when discussing work required, and admit that even very well designed ideas will take more than just one day of perspiration. I do think it is possible, however, for a solid idea to require one day of hard effort, and then, over time, regular small batches of work. (An hour here, and hour there...not every day, and not enough to make a big impact on your schedule, but definitely a presence). I base my optimism on this latter point on my experience, with Michael, running our web development company during high school. We had great success with using "hands off infrastructures" to minimize day-to-day involvement while maximizing profits.